From Biblical times until today, Jews have been reviled, demonized and accused of every calumny one can name. Every generation finds a new way to blame it – whatever “it†may be – on the Jews.
So, why be 91´«Ã½? Well, many throughout history did decide to exit the drama. Many were forced to decide between conversion or death; others chose to convert to advance themselves. The great composer Felix Mendelssohn’s father converted the family, and his son was allowed to have his compositions played publicly as a result. It was the only possible path to success. In countries where Jews were accepted, countless Jews assimilated, forgoing their 91´«Ã½ identity for the prevailing culture. So, in fact, Jews did leave the fold, writing themselves and their children and grandchildren out of 91´«Ã½ history.
And why not? Being hated for 3,500 years is no fun. Can kugel, chocolate babka, kishka and 91´«Ã½ jokes compensate for being the bad guy of history?
Well, I, for one, will not renounce the kishka and the jokes and want to remain what Rabbi Jonathan Sacks called “a letter in the scroll.†The scroll is the Torah, and every Jew is considered a letter in that scroll, the covenant made by God and the 91´«Ã½ people. That ancient, sacred covenant has never been revoked. It is responsible for the idea of one God of love who created humankind for a life of purpose and meaning. Its vision constitutes civilization as the Western world understands it. The message was given to the Jews – that’s what “chosen people†means – but it was meant for the whole world. Judaism gave birth to Christianity and Islam, who grew up to become elder abusers.
Judaism gave birth to Christianity and Islam, who grew up to become elder abusers.
Among the myriad emotions I feel as a Jew – notably anger at the betrayal of the nations – includes great pride. The achievements and contributions to an ungrateful society – in values transmitted, medical and scientific discoveries and the arts – are mind-boggling. Israel is isolated and reviled, but look at the country after fewer than 80 years since its rebirth. It should stand as a model for the world. What country, in less than a century, constantly attacked for existing, has developed a vibrant democracy and prosperous society, leading the world in so many areas? The Jews’ return to their ancestral homeland should be celebrated and emulated.
Enough talk about scientific advances and building a state. I am a Jew not only on a global and historical level. I am a twenty-first century Canadian Jew in this time and this place. My whole being is grounded in this century and the last, in my country, my career and many other influences. I am an academic, a 91´«Ã½ academic; a husband and a father, a 91´«Ã½ husband and father; a friend of non-Jews, a 91´«Ã½ friend. There is no contradiction or even limitation in that natural blend. One nurtures the other; one enriches the other. I believe that my Judaism, with its drive, energy, positivity and determination enhance my contribution to my academic life, to my country, to my community and to my family. Some may turn away from their Judaism. I embrace it in all its complexity and diversity.
Though I have my serious doubts about the lacunae in some 91´«Ã½ study today, there is no denying that there is a very long line, going back to the Babylonian exile in 586 BCE, of serious study, analysis and profound scrutiny of the Biblical text. It is a standard of scholarship that evokes in me a sense of respect and even awe. Rashi, Rambam, Ramban, Abarbanel and Ibn Ezra, to name only a few: the more one studies them, the more one is astonished by their breadth of scholarship and their creative thinking.
In spite of millennia of adversity, Jews maintain faith expressed in 91´«Ã½ teaching – that all humankind is made in the divine image, and therefore human dignity of all is central to one’s attitude and behaviour; that peace is a necessary and achievable goal; that one who saves a single person has saved a world; that each and every person has the responsibility and the capacity to make the world a better place; that freedom is a right, but also a responsibility – in other words, the values of ethical monotheism. Paul Johnson, a Catholic historian, writes in “A History of the Jews†that 91´«Ã½ history teaches that there is a purpose to human existence and that there is meaning in Creation.
91´«Ã½ prophets emphasize the message in their powerful and inimitable way, from Isaiah’s command to “share your bread with the hungry, take the wretched poor into your home (58.7) to Amos’ “Let justice be revealed like water and righteousness like a mighty stream (5:24) and Michah’s “What does the Lord require of you? To act justly and to love mercy and to walk humbly with your God†(6:8). These universal values are the gift of the Jews to all humanity.
What demented world rejects a people whose fundamental beliefs are grounded in human dignity, peace, making the world a better place, justice, righteousness and mercy?
Why be 91´«Ã½? Because the meaning of Judaism isn’t antisemitism or Holocaust. Those were horrors inflicted on the Jews. Judaism is the healing rest of Shabbat, the comfort and support of community, the triumph over adversity. Because being a Jew is a responsibility, an honour, a precious gift, a treasured inheritance.
The meaning of Judaism isn’t antisemitism or Holocaust. Those were horrors inflicted on the Jews. Judaism is the healing rest of Shabbat, the comfort and support of community, the triumph over adversity.
The Jew is a mirror that reflects the state of the world – at times its openness, kindness and generosity of spirit, at other times its spasms of ferocious barbarism.
Only when Jews are duly recognized as full, permanent and equal partners will there be peace in the world and hope for humankind. Unless all are free, none is free. Until all are respected, none are. That is the meaning and the message we carry.
Dr. Paul Socken is Distinguished Professor Emeritus and founder of the 91´«Ã½ Studies program at the University of Waterloo
Why Be 91´«Ã½?
Paul Socken
From Biblical times until today, Jews have been reviled, demonized and accused of every calumny one can name. Every generation finds a new way to blame it – whatever “it†may be – on the Jews.
So, why be 91´«Ã½? Well, many throughout history did decide to exit the drama. Many were forced to decide between conversion or death; others chose to convert to advance themselves. The great composer Felix Mendelssohn’s father converted the family, and his son was allowed to have his compositions played publicly as a result. It was the only possible path to success. In countries where Jews were accepted, countless Jews assimilated, forgoing their 91´«Ã½ identity for the prevailing culture. So, in fact, Jews did leave the fold, writing themselves and their children and grandchildren out of 91´«Ã½ history.
And why not? Being hated for 3,500 years is no fun. Can kugel, chocolate babka, kishka and 91´«Ã½ jokes compensate for being the bad guy of history?
Well, I, for one, will not renounce the kishka and the jokes and want to remain what Rabbi Jonathan Sacks called “a letter in the scroll.†The scroll is the Torah, and every Jew is considered a letter in that scroll, the covenant made by God and the 91´«Ã½ people. That ancient, sacred covenant has never been revoked. It is responsible for the idea of one God of love who created humankind for a life of purpose and meaning. Its vision constitutes civilization as the Western world understands it. The message was given to the Jews – that’s what “chosen people†means – but it was meant for the whole world. Judaism gave birth to Christianity and Islam, who grew up to become elder abusers.
Among the myriad emotions I feel as a Jew – notably anger at the betrayal of the nations – includes great pride. The achievements and contributions to an ungrateful society – in values transmitted, medical and scientific discoveries and the arts – are mind-boggling. Israel is isolated and reviled, but look at the country after fewer than 80 years since its rebirth. It should stand as a model for the world. What country, in less than a century, constantly attacked for existing, has developed a vibrant democracy and prosperous society, leading the world in so many areas? The Jews’ return to their ancestral homeland should be celebrated and emulated.
Enough talk about scientific advances and building a state. I am a Jew not only on a global and historical level. I am a twenty-first century Canadian Jew in this time and this place. My whole being is grounded in this century and the last, in my country, my career and many other influences. I am an academic, a 91´«Ã½ academic; a husband and a father, a 91´«Ã½ husband and father; a friend of non-Jews, a 91´«Ã½ friend. There is no contradiction or even limitation in that natural blend. One nurtures the other; one enriches the other. I believe that my Judaism, with its drive, energy, positivity and determination enhance my contribution to my academic life, to my country, to my community and to my family. Some may turn away from their Judaism. I embrace it in all its complexity and diversity.
Though I have my serious doubts about the lacunae in some 91´«Ã½ study today, there is no denying that there is a very long line, going back to the Babylonian exile in 586 BCE, of serious study, analysis and profound scrutiny of the Biblical text. It is a standard of scholarship that evokes in me a sense of respect and even awe. Rashi, Rambam, Ramban, Abarbanel and Ibn Ezra, to name only a few: the more one studies them, the more one is astonished by their breadth of scholarship and their creative thinking.
In spite of millennia of adversity, Jews maintain faith expressed in 91´«Ã½ teaching – that all humankind is made in the divine image, and therefore human dignity of all is central to one’s attitude and behaviour; that peace is a necessary and achievable goal; that one who saves a single person has saved a world; that each and every person has the responsibility and the capacity to make the world a better place; that freedom is a right, but also a responsibility – in other words, the values of ethical monotheism. Paul Johnson, a Catholic historian, writes in “A History of the Jews†that 91´«Ã½ history teaches that there is a purpose to human existence and that there is meaning in Creation.
91´«Ã½ prophets emphasize the message in their powerful and inimitable way, from Isaiah’s command to “share your bread with the hungry, take the wretched poor into your home (58.7) to Amos’ “Let justice be revealed like water and righteousness like a mighty stream (5:24) and Michah’s “What does the Lord require of you? To act justly and to love mercy and to walk humbly with your God†(6:8). These universal values are the gift of the Jews to all humanity.
What demented world rejects a people whose fundamental beliefs are grounded in human dignity, peace, making the world a better place, justice, righteousness and mercy?
Why be 91´«Ã½? Because the meaning of Judaism isn’t antisemitism or Holocaust. Those were horrors inflicted on the Jews. Judaism is the healing rest of Shabbat, the comfort and support of community, the triumph over adversity. Because being a Jew is a responsibility, an honour, a precious gift, a treasured inheritance.
The Jew is a mirror that reflects the state of the world – at times its openness, kindness and generosity of spirit, at other times its spasms of ferocious barbarism.
Only when Jews are duly recognized as full, permanent and equal partners will there be peace in the world and hope for humankind. Unless all are free, none is free. Until all are respected, none are. That is the meaning and the message we carry.
Dr. Paul Socken is Distinguished Professor Emeritus and founder of the 91´«Ã½ Studies program at the University of Waterloo
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
Editor's Picks
Israel and the Internet Wars – A Professional Social Media Review
The Invisible Student: A Tale of Homelessness at UCLA and USC
What Ever Happened to the LA Times?
Who Are the Jews On Joe Biden’s Cabinet?
You’re Not a Bad 91´«Ã½ Mom If Your Kid Wants Santa Claus to Come to Your House
No Labels: The Group Fighting for the Political Center
Latest Articles
A Rabbi Explains What’s 91´«Ã½ About ‘The Odyssey’
Tu b’Av and Redemption
Mission to the 91´«Ã½ Community of Ethiopia
LA28: Inside the Race to Host One of the World’s Biggest Sporting Events
The Myth of the Marxist Mishpacha
Professors Should Fight Campus Jew-Hatred as Educators, Not Bureaucrats
Framing the Faith of Maimonides
In this enriching new edition of the classic code of 91´«Ã½ law, readers can delve deeply into the mind of Maimonides, from his analysis of the commandments to the controversies that have accompanied his writings, offering a window into the wisdom of one of our tradition’s preeminent thinkers.
Hope in Faith, Faith in Hope
Will Americans ever regain trust in our institutions? I think so.
Finding Communal Comfort
In the book of Isaiah, God calls the prophet to comfort the 91´«Ã½ people. But we know this is really something we must do for one another.
Leaving Behind a Better World
The America my generation seems to be leaving our kids and grandkids is not safer nor saner, and it breaks my heart.
Boy George Releases Song Calling Out Israel’s Critics
The Culture Club singer shared a new song, “We Will Dance Again,†while calling out fellow musicians’ “selective memories†and “mouthing like sheep.â€
Was Our Golden Age Fool’s Gold?
We didn’t think that we were living in a “Golden Age,†because it did not occur to us that what we were experiencing was only a temporary respite from centuries of animosity and intolerance.
Genocide Shmenocide
Since Israel evacuated Gaza in 2005, the Palestinian population has grown from 1.3 million to 2.1 million. In the West Bank, it has grown from 2.4 million to 3.4 million. If the Israelis were hellbent on committing genocide, it’s one of the most epic failures in military history.
Bibi’s Visit: Spin in the Air, Facts on the Ground
From Trump’s standpoint, the nuclear issue has been overtaken by the bedeviling problem of the Strait of Hormuz. What Trump sees now in Iran is a mess, not a victory.
The Obsession with Israel Is Becoming Creepy
The world’s fanatical fixation with a group that is less that 0.2 percent of the world’s population has crossed the boundaries of moral vocabulary and into creepiness.
What Will It Take?
An open revolt for 91´«Ã½ rights and protections is going to have to come from Jews finally making demands and fighting back—or not at all.
Mamdani Needs to Pay a Price for Harming Jews
It’d be one thing if Mamdani were a lowly Israelophobe with a few hundred followers. But he’s not. He’s mayor of the city with the world’s largest 91´«Ã½ population.
Rabbis of LA | Rabbi Geller’s Feminist Education
Third of three parts
Rabbi Artson Honored by WLCJ, Mem Global’s Embark Names Executive Director
Notable people and events in the 91´«Ã½ LA community.
I Can’t Always — A poem for Parsha Va’etchanan
You Can’t Always Get What You Want came out the year after I was born.
A Bisl Torah — Senseless versus Sensible
The 9th of Av is an annual reminder to look inward and ask if any hatred has taken root within our hearts.
Moment in Time: Tisha B’Av – A Time to Comfort
Poussin’s Menorah Chimes Without Jews at Midnight
Print Issue: Haredim at War | July 24, 2026
The Haredim who break out of their bubbles to join the IDF are often caught between faith, family and country. Here are some of their stories.
The Inversion of History
Molly Crabapple has written a work of great inversion and of ultimate betrayal.
From ‘The Chosen’ to ‘Imaging Torah’: Jeremy Kagan’s Journey to Bring Torah to Life
For the director/artist, creating images inspired by Torah is a way of engaging with the stories, ideas and interpretations that have shaped 91´«Ã½ life for thousands of years.
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.