fbpx

91传媒

Judge Strikes Down Female Genital Mutilation Law

[additional-authors]
November 21, 2018

A judge struck down a 1996 federal law banning female genital mutilation, saying that it was incompatible with the Constitution.

The Michigan case at hand involved Dr. Jumana Nargawala who allegedly performed female genital mutilation on nine girls, who were reportedly in the age range of 7-12 years old. Nagarawala is also alleged to have two of the girls into the procedure, as one of the girls was told that the procedure was to clean out bacteria and afterward a medical examination found damage to her genitals.

Nargawala has denied the allegations, stating that she performed a benign procedure on the girls.

The judge, Bernard Friedman, argued that the federal government didn鈥檛 have jurisdiction over the matter because female genital mutilation doesn鈥檛 constitute interstate commerce.

鈥淎s despicable as this practice may be, it is essentially a criminal assault,鈥 Friedman . 鈥淔GM is not part of a larger market and it has no demonstrated effect聽on interstate commerce. The commerce clause does not permit Congress to regulate a crime of this nature.鈥

Consequently, the six charges under the FGM law against Nargawala were dropped, as were charges against Dr. Fakhruddin Attar, who allegedly allowed Nargawala to use his facility for FGM, and his wife Farida Attar, of providing aid to Nargawala.

Molly Blythe, an attorney for Nargawala, National Public Radio (NPR): 鈥淭he law warranted this decision, and we are happy with it.鈥

Nargawala and the Attars still face charges of conspiracy and obstruction. The federal government is looking into appealing the ruling.

The ruling has sparked outrage. Ayaan Hirsi Ali, a survivor of FGM, tweeted:

The Washington Examiner鈥檚 Tiana Lowe the ruling 鈥渁 bending of the law to protect and normalize systemic violence against women.鈥

鈥淓ven the most limited, contemporary reading of the Commerce Clause would allow Congress to protect minors from being forcibly shoved across state lines to undergo medically detrimental torture. (One of the victims was drugged with Valium to make her compliant.),鈥 Lowe wrote.

Jaha Dukureh, who like Ali is a survivor of FGM, NPR, 鈥淪ome women have partial or total removal of the clitoris [a small, highly sensitive part of the genitalia]; some have the folds of flesh around the vagina removed; some have both those areas removed; some have the vaginal opening narrowed, often by stitching, and some women have some form of piercing, scraping, cauterizing to genitalia.鈥

Dukureh added that there are no health benefits to FGM and it鈥檚 generally done as a religious procedure to control women鈥檚 sexual impulses.

There are 27 states that currently have laws banning FGM, including Michigan.

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
  • 91传媒

Editor's Picks

Latest Articles

The Obsession with Israel Is Becoming Creepy

The world鈥檚 fanatical fixation with a group that is less that 0.2 percent of the world鈥檚 population has crossed the boundaries of moral vocabulary and into creepiness.

What Will It Take?

An open revolt for 91传媒 rights and protections is going to have to come from Jews finally making demands and fighting back鈥攐r not at all.

Mamdani Needs to Pay a Price for Harming Jews

It鈥檇 be one thing if Mamdani were a lowly Israelophobe with a few hundred followers. But he鈥檚 not. He鈥檚 mayor of the city with the world鈥檚 largest 91传媒 population.

Three Dates to Dataland

I took three different dates, ages 6, 72 and 35, to see Dataland, the unusual digital art experience in downtown Los Angeles.

Hakol Shalom, All Is Shalom

This is the transcript of the speech Rabbi Dr. Bradley Shavit Artson gave at the 2026 AJU Gala on May 19, 2026.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.

  • 91传媒